Agri-PV is widely seen as a way to ease the competition for land between farming and energy generation. But it can take a long time to get such a system built, and planners and farmers have to clear a number of hurdles along the way if the project is to succeed.
Good preparation goes a long way. “Those who act early will benefit,” says Niklas Kreifels of Diveo. The Freiburg-based company has spent several years planning and building agri-PV systems, some of them with integrated storage and some without. Over that time, Kreifels has come across most of the challenges these projects face, and he says the first questions come up even before planning starts.
Checking for restrictions
First, farmers need to find out whether their land is suitable for agri-PV at all. The tool for this is a restriction analysis, which checks the site step by step against the rules on nature conservation, spatial planning and infrastructure. One of the main questions is whether the law allows a system to be built on the site at all. “If you miss something here, it may later turn out to rule the site out completely,” Kreifels says. “Then you have spent a lot of time, and maybe money too, on a project you can’t build.”
Sites that are ruled out completely include nature reserves, national parks, peat soils, core areas of the biotope network and zone 1 water protection areas. In some designated areas, however, agri-PV is at an advantage. Farmers in priority areas for agriculture are not allowed to install conventional ground-mounted solar systems. Agri-PV systems are an exception, as long as they are designed in line with the rules, says Kreifels.
Talking to the authorities early
Other restrictions are more complicated, because each case has to be assessed individually.A landscape protection area, for example, does not automatically rule out a project, and the outcome depends on what the area is meant to protect. If the aim is to preserve the landscape, it can help to point to similar systems that have already been approved in comparable locations.
EnergyDecentral: storage and power marketing gain ground with farmers
In many cases, sightlines also have to be assessed. The question is whether the planned system can be seen from certain points, such as footpaths, the edges of villages or viewpoints, and how much it would change the landscape. Often, a call to the relevant authority clears up these questions early on, before money goes into an expensive expert report. “It’s better to pick up the phone early and talk to the authorities,” Kreifels advises. A conversation with the local nature conservation authority can also spare farmers unwelcome surprises later.
Lining up rows and rotations
Orientation also plays a part in whether a site is suitable. The rows of modules should follow the direction in which the land is worked as closely as possible, and this helps decide whether agri-PV is possible on the site and, if so, which type. For tracker systems, which turn the modules to follow the sun, Kreifels recommends a north-south working axis. The trackers then face east in the morning and west in the evening, which gives the best yield. “In practice, that’s rarely possible to achieve perfectly,” he explains. “But for the power yield, it isn’t a big problem if the axis is turned slightly, or even by several degrees, away from a perfect north-south line. The systems still deliver a good enough yield.”
Solar Investors Guide #11 – Agri-PV reimagines farmland for the future
Farmers also need to be clear about how the land will be used. Alongside elevated systems for specialty crops, Diveo focuses on tracker systems, which are usually installed on arable land. Here, the planned crop rotation has to suit the use of agri-PV. In Kreifels’s experience, cereal rotations combined with legumes generally work very well with photovoltaics, and soya has also proved a good fit. But farmers who want to grow tall, light-hungry crops such as maize should think carefully before investing in agri-PV. (su)
Read the full report in our latest PV for farmers special. Register to download it for free.